Back to all resources

Legal Experts Analyze Constitutional Grounds for Trump's Impeachment

Updated: June 15, 2023
Legal Experts Analyze Constitutional Grounds for Trump's Impeachment

A panel of constitutional law scholars has weighed in on the legal basis for impeaching former President Donald Trump, offering varied perspectives on whether his actions meet the threshold for "high crimes and misdemeanors" as specified in the Constitution.

Professor Elaine Murray of Georgetown Law Center argued that the evidence demonstrates a clear pattern of abuse of power: "The Framers explicitly designed impeachment as a remedy for abuse of public trust. The President's actions, using his office for personal political gain, represent precisely the kind of misconduct they sought to prevent."

However, Professor Jonathan Hayes of Harvard Law School cautioned that impeachment should be reserved for the most egregious violations: "While the President's conduct was concerning, we must be careful not to lower the bar for what constitutes an impeachable offense. The Constitution sets a high standard for good reason."

The scholars also addressed the question of whether a president can be impeached after leaving office. Most agreed that historical precedent supports this possibility, citing the case of Secretary of War William Belknap who was impeached in 1876 after his resignation.

"Impeachment serves not only to remove an official from office but also to disqualify them from holding future office," explained constitutional historian Dr. Rebecca Chen. "This latter function remains relevant even after a president's term has expired."

As Congress proceeds with the impeachment process, these constitutional questions will likely continue to be debated by legal scholars, politicians, and the American public.